OH PLEASE – AT 1:14 P.M. ET: The administration and its press boosters are becoming desperate to justify the upcoming Iran nuclear deal, which looks as if it will have more holes than Swiss cheese. The latest member of the choir to sing is the well-known Fareed Zakaria, a sometime adviser to Barack Obama From IBD:
Of the many unnerving aspects of the Middle East's future, a nuclear arms race would top the list. And it is to feed that unease that Saudi Arabia has been periodically dropping hints that, if Iran's nuclear ambitions go unchecked, it might just have to get nuclear weapons itself.
Last week, the Saudi ambassador to London made yet another threat, warning that "all options will be on the table."
Oh, please! Saudi Arabia isn't going to build a nuclear weapon. Saudi Arabia can't build a nuclear weapon. Saudi Arabia hasn't even built a car. (By 2017, after much effort, the country is expected to manufacture its first automobile.)
Saudi Arabia can dig holes in the ground and pump out oil, but little else. Oil revenue is about 45% of its GDP, a staggeringly high figure, much larger than petrostates like Nigeria and Venezuela. It makes up almost 90% of the Saudi government's revenues. Despite decades of massive government investment, lavish subsidies and cheap energy, manufacturing is less than 10% of Saudi GDP.
Where would Saudi Arabia train the scientists to work on its secret program? The country's education system is backward and dysfunctional, having been largely handed over to its puritanical and reactionary religious establishment. The country ranks 73rd in the quality of its math and science education, according to the World Economic Forum — abysmally low for a rich country. Iran, despite 36 years of sanctions and a much lower per capita GDP, fares far better at 44.
COMMENT: Under the logic of Zakaria's argument, we can ask how Pakistan got the bomb? Money buys a lot, and experts can be hired. The financing is there. Nuclear knowledge is fairly easy to come by. Building a nuclear bomb isn't a scientific project, it's an engineering project. (Researchers knew how to build at atomic bomb before World War II. They just didn't have the engineering programs and facilities to test their ideas.)
If the Saudis want a bomb, they'll get one, with foreign help, for which they'll pay lavishly. Zakaria is parroting the line that a bad nuclear agreement with Iran won't lead to a Mideast arms race. I wouldn't bet on that.
June 12, 2015 |